What is a critique? Writing a critique.
CRITIQUE OF A SCIENTIFIC PAPER OR JOURNAL ARTICLE. Writing tips.
The critique usually never exceeds 2000 words. The article chosen should be one that will be listed in the bibliography of his/her research proposal. There is no restriction on choice of subject matter but the selected article should be from a refereed/reputable journal and should include methodology and study design issues.
Details of how to conduct a critique of article are as follows:
Structure of a critique:
Read the selected article.
The following questions may be used as a guide to evaluate the journal article and help you write quality article critique
While you may add additional headings and comments, the following structure of a crique is the most commonly used and expected in American universities.
- Research Problem
State the research problem.
Was the research problem clearly stated?
Were the specific questions for research specified, or can they be implied?
Were the general and specific objectives of the study specified or implied?
State the general and specific objectives of the study.
- Literature Review
Was the literature up to date?
Was the literature critically reviewed and appraised?
State the hypotheses of this study (if applicable)
- Study Design
State the study design
- Study Population
What were the units of observation in this study?
What were the criteria used for inclusion or exclusion of study subjects?
- Data collected and study variables
What were the data collected?
What were the independent and dependent variables?
What was the sampling technique?
Were the study subjects selected as representative samples?
To which population can the results of this study be generalized?
What controls were used?
Were the study and control groups reasonably comparable?
What criteria were used to show comparability of study and control groups?
- Study Instruments
What study instruments were used in this study?
Was the study instrument properly calibrated/validated/pretested?
Were ethical problems adequately considered?
- Flow Chart
Draw a flow chart to summarize the study
- Duration of Study
What was the study period?
Were the methods of statistical analysis used appropriate for the study design?
-Which statistical tests were used?
Did the authors control for confounding?
Were the results appropriately tabulated?
Were the methods of analysis adequate with respect to significance testing?
- What significance level was used?
- If the method of analysis is inappropriate what other statistical tests would you suggest?
Were the conclusions based on the results of the study, or were they biased?
Are the results of this study consistent with the findings of other research, other investigators’ experiences and your readings?
Are the findings of this study valid?
Can the results of this study be accepted?
What are the implications or significance of the findings of this study?
Can the results be generalized to the target population?
- Overall Evaluation of Study
Discuss the strengths and limitations of this study. Did the author draw his conclusions in the light of the limitations of his study?
EssayPlant.com professional writers and editors can assist you in preparation of your Critique. Their vast writing experience allows them to understand the topic and quickly develop a successful article critique on your topic. Please proceed to the order page to buy custom critique now to quickly turn your writings and ideas in a quality masterpiece!